To
Catch a Killer
By
David King
With
the click of a button, Kurt Mausert located the man indicted
in the stabbing death of his brother, something prosecutors
failed to do for 27 years
In
1979, 21-year-old Kurt Mausert care-fully tailed a car through
the streets of Honolulu. He thought the vehicle carried the
man who had stabbed his brother in the heart. Knowing that
police had allowed this man to flee the country once before,
Mausert had taken things into his own hands; he was not going
to give the killer another chance to get away. But Mauserts
days of surveillance came to an abrupt end when he discovered
that the car he was trailing was not being driven by the man
he sought. That man was, in fact, still somewhere safe in
his home country.
Twenty-seven years later, after many abortive attempts at
justice and a life shaped by the quest, Mausert, now a successful
defense attorney and a resident of Schuylerville, was on the
hunt again. This time, he was sitting in front of a computer
in his Saratoga Springs office, ready to give his quest for
justice one last shot. Slowly he typed the name of the man
who had been arrested and indicted for the murder of his brother
into the empty space on Google.com. Then he clicked the search
button.
On Feb. 22, 1979, Kurts brother Eric, who (like Kurt) was
a Hare Krishna devotee, was accompanying a recently married
couple on their way to the airport in Honolulu. Although the
couple were trying to escape their parents, who disapproved
of their new religion, the bride insisted she stop at her
parents house to say goodbye. Another member of the Krishna
temple accompanied the couple into the home, where the parents
tried to trap them. According to witnesses and police, after
a scuffle, the couple ran from the home, followed by the brides
irate brother, Juvenal Llaneza.
Eric
gets out of the car and raises his arms and yells, Stop!
He didnt assume a violent position; he just wanted to stop
what he saw as an escalating, violent situation, says Kurt.
Erics pleas for calm fell on deaf ears and he found himself
under attack.
My
brother knew he had gotten hit. . . . He says, OK, you can
hit. Then Im gonna hit back. He does not know he has been
stabbed, at this point, says Kurt. Eric had been stabbed
directly in the heart with a five-inch blade. He put his
arms down and decked Llaneza. With Llaneza on the ground,
Eric notices the guys got blood on the front of him and
realizes that blood is spurting from his own heart.
Later, Kurt says, I saw the puncture wound in my brothers
body. The knife would have been hard to see in daylight, not
to speak of the evening or dusk. Erics companion told Kurt
that his brother did not suffer, and that when he told him
to leave his body and think of Krishna, Eric nodded his head
that he was. When police finally arrived, Llaneza was arrested.
Then, after two days, he was released. Llanezas father put
him on a plane back to his home country, the Philippines.
Kurt insists that Llaneza was allowed to flee because of his
fathers status as a Philippino diplomat.
Not knowing Llaneza had fled the country, Kurt Mausert boarded
a plane and headed for Hawaii to oversee his brothers cremation.
This first trip to Hawaii would also include Mauserts first
attempt to push for justice in his brothers slaying. It would
not be his last. For the past 27 years, his struggle has been
marked by multiple starts and stops and painful disappointments
that have left him wondering if anyone really wants to try
the man accused of stabbing his brother.
It began on that 1979 trip, when for five weeks, Mausert says,
he tried to persuade police and prosecutors to re-arrest Llaneza,
to no avail. No one from the county attorneys office or
the police department tells me that this guy is gone, he
says. They allow me to have the illusion that I actually
have the chance to catch the guy.
Kurts older brother Mark was at the McGeorge School of Law
in Sacramento, Calif., at the time.
He
went to his dean to explain the situation. As Kurt tells it,
the dean said, Lets see who Ive got as an alumnus. He
finds a U.S. attorney and he says, Will you look into this?
They call the county attorney and ask, What are you guys
doing? Whats the story? They tell him, Oh, this guys left
the country. Thats how I find out.
Confused by the way the case had been handled, Mark called
to speak to the Honolulu county prosecutor. Mark says he was
told by Larry Grean, a member of the county attorneys screening
intake division, that there was no way to indict the man because
he had escaped the country. Mark says he knew that wasnt
true, and that after he quizzed Grean on the legal particulars,
the guy, he just clams up. So I told him, Larry, you are
a fucking whore!
Kurt says a grand jury eventually was convened to indict Llaneza,
but no evidence was offered and no witnesses were called to
testify. After pressure from the Mausert family, a second
grand jury was impaneled and Llaneza was indicted on a charge
of manslaughter. However, he was long gone and there was no
way to bring him back; in 1979 the United States had no extradition
treaty with the Philippines.
Defeated, Kurt Mausert settled in California and decided to
take up Erics work indexing sacred Krishna texts. Although
he says he was happy with the work, he soon found himself
obsessing over his brothers murder. Nine months later, after
receiving various tips about his brothers killer, Mausert
went back to Hawaii, as he puts it, playing private detective.
Although his attempt to track the accused killer himself proved
fruitless, Mausert continued to keep up his calls to the county
prosecutor to see if the warrant for Llaneza was still in
place. Nearly 20 years later, in 1998, Kurt received a jolt
of hope when an investigator told him his case was being reopened
and the office was going to aggressively go after Llaneza
with or without an extradition treaty.
Two years after that, having heard nothing, Mausert contacted
the investigator, and, he says, It was a completely different
tune. Oh, no, we cant get him without an extradition treaty,
and Oh, hes gonna be really hard to find in the Philippines.
They arent computerized like we are. There is nothing we
can do. So I put the file away. I figure, what the hell,
Im just gonna live with this til the day I die.
Kurt Mauserts attempts to see justice in his brothers murder
have weighed heavily on his life decisions.
First, I wanted to go make war on the criminal element, so
I tried to become a cop, he says, but he wasnt accepted.
The LAPD wasnt taking white males. . . . [so] I went to
law school because I realized that I was never gonna grow
up and be tough enough to be Batman.
Determined to become a prosecutor, Mausert worked his way
through school doing something he had dreamed of doing as
a kid: coloring comic books. He also studied martial arts
and lethal self defense.
My
brothers murder certainly changed my view of the world,
he says. He was larger than life; he was Captain America.
The idea that some little punk with a tiny knife could take
his life really turned my world upside down. I realized how
dangerous a place the world can be and I made a decision that
I will not go quietly. If Im ever in a situation like that
I want to be trained, and I dont ever want my family members
to live with the pain that Ive had to live with for the last
27 years because I dont come home to them.
Mausert makes it clear that he is ready to take a life if
he is attacked. My brothers murder was the formative moment
in my life, he says, leading him to an existence based on
a battle between fear and prudence.
I
think Ive made my peace with Krishna, he muses. Being a
parent, having kids has helped me do that, but its put a
lot of fear in my life. Im gonna teach my children martial
arts. They are gonna learn to take precautions for their safety.
Why? Because for 17 years Ive been practicing law. Ive seen
the evil people do to each other. I see ugliness every day
come across my desk. My wife thinks I sometimes have a slanted
view of the world. I sometimes think I have a slanted
view, but other times I think I have the real view and it
is everyone who does not practice [law], who isnt a cop,
or [who doesnt] work in emergency care, that doesnt see
the fallout from how we treat each other as a species, who
have a slanted view.
I
had lunch with a friend who said, You know, Kurt, I dont
live in that world. I said to him, Yeah, Bob you do. You
just dont see it.
Still, practicing law in the real world after college made
Mausert realize he could not achieve his goals or uphold his
principles while working as a prosecutor. Ironically, the
man who is haunted by a criminal not brought to justice became
a criminal-defense attorney. There is a common thread, though:
fighting corruption and favoritism in the legal system, which
he first encountered in the county prosecutors who abused
their authority and let my brothers killer go because he
had political connections.
Mausert has become noted for going after judges and prosecutors
he believes are corrupt.
Ive
spent most of my career defending individuals against criminal
charges, Kurt says. Some of them are innocent; some of them
arent. But Ive run into one or more district attorney that
makes decisions not based on the law and the facts but based
on who knows who, based on political favoritism. Whenever
I run into that, I feel an old heat come into me, and I know
its my old issue. I know it is why I became an attorney,
and I have zero tolerance for it and I go after them real
hard.
But all this work and passion for his practice didnt exorcise
his obsession with his brothers murder. A few years into
his career as a defense attorney, Mausert called Larry Grean
at the Honolulu district attorneys office. I say, This
is Kurt Mausert. Do you recognize my name? You let my brothers
killer go in 1979. Im an attorney now. Ive been practicing
defense law for two years and prior to that I was a prosecutor.
Im having trouble sleeping at night. Do you sleep at night?
And if so, tell me how. He had nothing to say.
In the fall of 2005, on what he describes as a lark, Mausert
asked his secretary to check with the U.S. State Department
to see if an extradition treaty with the Philippines had ever
been signed. To his surprise, a treaty had been on the books
since 1996. They either lied to me in 98 and 2000 or theyre
stupid, and either qualitydishonesty or incompetenceis not
a quality you want in a prosecutor, he says. But he still
gave them a chance to make good.
I
call [the investigator] and say, There is a treaty. Remember
me? There is a treaty. Here is the treaty number. I personally
spoke with the State Department. They said its retroactive
for crimes happening before the treaty was passed. The investigator
assured him that they would find Llaneza.
Having so easily found the extradition treaty, Mausert decided
to press his luck. I said, I own stock in Google. Lets
see if the thing works. I put [Llanezas] name in and 20
seconds later Ive got his face up on the computer, and he
works on the board of directors of the Manila Trucking Corporation.
So I call [the investigator] back and say, Not only have
I found the treaty, I found Llaneza! He says, No way! How
did you do it? I say, I Googled him. So much for not being
able to find the guy. Here is your treaty, here is your killer.
Go get im.
Finally, the Mausert brothers journey for justice seemed
to be nearing an end. The man who Googled his brothers murderer
made news around the country. Having presented prosecutors
with the two things they had said would be key to bringing
the man accused of killing Eric to justice, it seemed like
a matter of time before he was brought in front of a jury.
Instead, they have so far found themselves in a rerun of former
disappointments. The county attorneys office has refused
to prosecute the case and has shipped it to a cold-case unit
under the jurisdiction of the Hawaii attorney general.
The county prosecutors office refuses to answer questions
about the Mausert case and directed Metroland to the
state attorney general. However, The Honolulu Advertiser
spoke with Peter Carlisle, the Honolulu County attorney, earlier
this month. Carlisle said that he decided his office could
not handle the case because Larry Grean pressed charges against
Mark Mausert after Mark supposedly made threatening comments
in 1991. Mark insists he never made any threats and simply
wanted, and wants, to know what is delaying his brothers
case.
Representatives of the Hawaii attorney generals cold-case
division have told reporters that they are committed to completing
the case, but have noted it may be challenging to extradite
Llaneza.
Kurt insists that the last place his brothers case should
be is in a cold-case unit. Its not a cold case. One, [that]
means its not solved. Two, the trail of evidence is not cold.
This case is solved. The guys indicted. There is an open
indictment, and I just found him for you. Its not cold; it
hasnt been cold since a grand jury indicted him for manslaughter
in 1979!
Both brothers would simply like to know how a case with an
indicted suspect has gone so long unprosecuted. They both
desperately want their questions answered. Why didnt they
try him in absentia? asks Kurt. They wont explain any of
this. They wont answer any of these questions.
Ill
tell you why they dont want him brought back now, says Mark,
who also currently practices as a defense attorney. Cause
when Llaneza is brought back, I know as a defense lawyer.
. . . I would say that the state has sat on its hands for
27 years and hasnt done anything and therefore people and
evidence have disappeared, evidence has gone stale. Mark
says there is only one sure way to defeat that defense, and
he is certain that the Honolulu prosecutors dont want to
open that can of worms. To successfully defeat it, you show
that his flight was a result of a conspiracy. The problem,
says Mark, is that that approach opens wide to an inquiry:
How did this happen? Why wasnt his passport taken? Bond taken?
Thats why it will never see the inside of a courtroom.
Kurt and Mark Mausert are left stuck with little hope, trying
to adjust, again, to the idea that justice likely will never
be done.
Mark no longer blames Llaneza for his familys suffering.
This is something he likely did in the heat of passion. If
he is any kind of a human being, he has had to suffer with
this for 27 years. Its the people who are subverting justice
willingly who need to answer for what theyve done.
That does not, however, mean he has forgiven his brothers
killer. The criminal justice system clears the deck for victims
to be able to forgive. Thats the healing process, and when
you subvert the system the way it has been, it leaves the
wound open.
The religion his brother Eric taught him has been the one
thing that has allowed Kurt to find some peace. He says his
brother died a noble death with his mind and heart fixed on
Krishna, facing an enemy while protecting another devotee
from unwarranted attack.
What
I believe is that because of this he attained the supreme
destination, to escape the cycle of birth and death and not
to have to come back to the physical world, says Kurt. Im
sure he would say it was a good death, but that still leaves
me stuck. That still leaves me without the person.
|