By Chet
Hardin
Mgc0216,
or Mike, has a couple credit cards he wants to consolidate
at a lower interest rate. Plus, he just started an RV-rental
company this summer, and he needs a little extra money to
keep him solvent through the down season. So he goes online
to Prosper.com. There he secures a $25,000 loan at 14-percent
interest.
“That’s
a pretty aggressive rate for that amount of money,” he says.
He has a pretty good credit rating and job history, and private
lenders are comfortable with that rate.
Then,
there is Monica, who first went on Prosper.com back when it
started in February 2006. She wanted to borrow $20,000 at
8.75-percent interest.
“Hey
everyone!” she wrote in her loan request. “I am a college
educated, responsible woman who lives in Chicago. I have an
awesome job as a tax consultant and I am looking to borrow
money to build up my credit and reinvest it to coup my costs.
I will not spend it! This is a very low risk deal, you get
guaranteed interest on your money, I invest it to coup those
costs, and you help me build my credit!”
She attached
a photo of herself: Young, lit in blue, with long brown hair,
she looks like someone you would want to grab sushi and a
movie with, but not someone you would want to loan large sums
of money to. But now, four loan requests later, she has learned
what it takes to attract lenders, and it looks as though she
will be getting her money—at a whopping 29-percent interest.
They
are just two of the thousands of registered users at Prosper.com,
which bills itself as “America’s first people-to-people lending
marketplace.” The site is established on a very simple premise:
Why go to a bank when you can go to complete strangers? Through
Prosper, people with money are able to connect with people
who need money. Anyone can sign up, and the process is relatively
simple.
Once
a prospective borrower is approved (identification is verified),
they can make a loan request for any amount from $1,000 to
$25,000, setting the maximum interest they are willing to
pay. They are assigned a credit rating—AA, A, B, C, D, F,
and HR (high risk)—and are given a full Web page to make their
pitch.
All loans
are made on a three-year payment plan, but a borrower can
pay off an entire loan immediately after receiving the money,
without penalty, if they want.
For the
prospective lender, the process is just as simple. They register,
transfer funds from their bank to Prosper, and that is it.
For as little as $50—the minimum amount one can loan out—they
are ready to become a cyber loan shark.
The potential
of growth within Prosper attracted Zach Maxfield, analyst
at Second Curve Capital in New York City, who signed up and
started loaning money out in July. “I thought it was a very
interesting idea that I wanted to try out. I don’t want to
say that it would have huge ramifications for the industry
if it works out,” he says. “It obviously is never going to
be as big as the credit-card industry. But I did want to see
what it was like, and test it and see whether or not the credits
would perform.”
Maxfield
suspected if the program were going to fail, it would fail
right away.
“If it
was going to be bad, it would be lots of first-payment defaults,
effectively just fraud. But I haven’t seen that,” he says.
“I have had a couple of delinquencies, but none that actually
went to default. I was actually a little surprised, because
I intentionally picked a lot of loans that were very far out
on the credit spectrum. But, thus far, everything has been
going great.”
Maxfield,
who has made 25 $50 loans, is averaging a return rate around
20 percent. Although that is a high return on his money, he
points out, if five of those loans go into default, that profit
will drop dramatically. He has been blogging about his experience
at Bankstocks.com.
If the
numbers tell the story, the story of Prosper so far has been
a success. Since opening in February, the site has registered
80,000 users. There has been $17.4 million loaned out through
Prosper in 3,600 loans. Of that amount, only $11,000 has gone
into default.
But fans
of this site say that this is about more than just the money.
It is about social networking. You can choose who you want
to invest in based on who they are. There is a social connection;
you are helping out someone in need. You can choose who to
invest your money in based on their situation, their story,
their picture.
This
is what attracted Tea-Fanatic. The San Fransisco-based entrepreneur
is seeking a $25,000 loan to continue construction work on
her retail tea shop. Her request features a photo of herself
leaning into a large barrel of green tea in a marketplace
in China.
The amount
of money she is borrowing from Prosper, when compared to all
the money she already has invested in her shop, is not huge,
she says. “But the idea is intriguing. It is a community of
people. The community supports your project.”
chardin@metroland.net